diff --git a/include/item.h b/include/item.h
index 1f3b1fab1b..56fe152720 100644
--- a/include/item.h
+++ b/include/item.h
@@ -215,6 +215,7 @@ bool32 CheckBagHasSpace(u16 itemId, u16 count);
 u32 GetFreeSpaceForItemInBag(u16 itemId);
 bool32 AddBagItem(u16 itemId, u16 count);
 bool32 RemoveBagItem(u16 itemId, u16 count);
+void RemoveBagItemFromSlot(struct BagPocket *pocket, u16 slotId, u16 count);
 u8 CountUsedPCItemSlots(void);
 bool32 CheckPCHasItem(u16 itemId, u16 count);
 bool32 AddPCItem(u16 itemId, u16 count);
diff --git a/src/item.c b/src/item.c
index 7519060287..5bfc59c68f 100644
--- a/src/item.c
+++ b/src/item.c
@@ -411,6 +411,13 @@ bool32 RemoveBagItem(u16 itemId, u16 count)
     return BagPocket_RemoveItem(&gBagPockets[GetItemPocket(itemId)], itemId, count);
 }
 
+// Unsafe function: Only use with functions that already check the slot and count are valid
+void RemoveBagItemFromSlot(struct BagPocket *pocket, u16 slotId, u16 count)
+{
+    struct ItemSlot itemSlot = BagPocket_GetSlotData(pocket, slotId);
+    BagPocket_SetSlotItemIdAndCount(pocket, slotId, itemSlot.itemId, itemSlot.quantity - count);
+}
+
 static u8 NONNULL BagPocket_CountUsedItemSlots(struct BagPocket *pocket)
 {
     u8 usedSlots = 0;
diff --git a/src/item_menu.c b/src/item_menu.c
index f19cad0cdc..e63758b3ac 100755
--- a/src/item_menu.c
+++ b/src/item_menu.c
@@ -170,6 +170,7 @@ static void PrintThereIsNoPokemon(u8);
 static void Task_ChooseHowManyToToss(u8);
 static void AskTossItems(u8);
 static void Task_RemoveItemFromBag(u8);
+static void Task_TossItemFromBag(u8 taskId);
 static void ItemMenu_Cancel(u8);
 static void HandleErrorMessage(u8);
 static void PrintItemCantBeHeld(u8);
@@ -1958,11 +1959,34 @@ static void ConfirmToss(u8 taskId)
     StringExpandPlaceholders(gStringVar4, gText_ThrewAwayVar2Var1s);
     FillWindowPixelBuffer(WIN_DESCRIPTION, PIXEL_FILL(0));
     BagMenu_Print(WIN_DESCRIPTION, FONT_NORMAL, gStringVar4, 3, 1, 0, 0, 0, COLORID_NORMAL);
-    gTasks[taskId].func = Task_RemoveItemFromBag;
+    if (CurrentBattlePyramidLocation() != PYRAMID_LOCATION_NONE || FlagGet(FLAG_STORING_ITEMS_IN_PYRAMID_BAG) == TRUE)
+        gTasks[taskId].func = Task_RemoveItemFromBag;
+    else
+        gTasks[taskId].func = Task_TossItemFromBag;
+}
+
+static void Task_TossItemFromBag(u8 taskId)
+{
+    s16 *data = gTasks[taskId].data;
+    u16 *scrollPos = &gBagPosition.scrollPosition[gBagPosition.pocket];
+    u16 *cursorPos = &gBagPosition.cursorPosition[gBagPosition.pocket];
+
+    if (JOY_NEW(A_BUTTON | B_BUTTON))
+    {
+        PlaySE(SE_SELECT);
+        RemoveBagItemFromSlot(&gBagPockets[gBagPosition.pocket], *scrollPos + *cursorPos, tItemCount);
+        DestroyListMenuTask(tListTaskId, scrollPos, cursorPos);
+        UpdatePocketItemList(gBagPosition.pocket);
+        UpdatePocketListPosition(gBagPosition.pocket);
+        LoadBagItemListBuffers(gBagPosition.pocket);
+        tListTaskId = ListMenuInit(&gMultiuseListMenuTemplate, *scrollPos, *cursorPos);
+        ScheduleBgCopyTilemapToVram(0);
+        ReturnToItemList(taskId);
+    }
 }
 
 // Remove selected item(s) from the bag and update list
-// For when items are tossed or deposited
+// For when items are deposited
 static void Task_RemoveItemFromBag(u8 taskId)
 {
     s16 *data = gTasks[taskId].data;